Showing posts with label My Digital Pull List. Show all posts
Showing posts with label My Digital Pull List. Show all posts

Saturday, October 29, 2011

The New 52 Month Two: Analyzing My Digital Pull List

Now that Month Two of the New 52 is over, which means I've had a chance to read at least the first issue of every series I plan to, it seems like a good idea to step back and take a look at the whole thing. And because I'm that kind of geek, when I say "step back and take a look," I mean "bust out Excel and plug in data in an attempt to quantify everything." So that's what I did. I entered the ratings I gave each of the first and second issues, averaged, sorted, and analyzed. Here's what I came up with:

  • I read 33 of the 52 first issues.
    • 15 day-and-date
    • 18 a month later
  • My average rating overall: 3.4 out of 5 Pixels
    • For Day-and-Date titles: 3.6 Pixels
    • For A Month Late titles: 3.25 Pixels
  • My favorite series: Batman and Stormwatch, each with an average of 4.25 Pixels over two issues.
  • In danger of being dropped if they don't get better quickly: Swamp Thing, Blue Beetle, Red Hood & the Outlaws, each with only 2.5 Pixels for the first issue.
  • Demoted from Day-and-Date to A Month Late after the first issue: Red Hood & the Outlaws
  • Comics that most pleasantly surprised me: Superboy and Frankenstein: Agent of S.H.A.D.E.
  • Comics that most disappointed me: Justice League International, Blue Beetle, and Red Hood & the Outlaws (JLI got a little better with the second issue; here's hoping the others do as well)
  • Comic that made the most significant improvement between issue 1 and issue 2 (so far): Wonder Woman, from 3 to 4 Pixels
  • Writers I am totally digging: Paul Cornell, Scott Snyder (despite Swamp Thing not really being my thing yet), Jeff Lemire, Geoff Johns, Grant Morrison (the last two are not new additions to this list as of the New 52, but the first three are)
  • Artists that are blowing my mind: J.H. Williams III, Francis Manapul.
  • Number one feel-good book: Batman & Robin
Overall, I'm enjoying this New 52 thing. Sure, there are a few mushy grapes in the bunch, but a good number of them are crisp and tasty.

Saturday, October 15, 2011

My Digital Pull List: Updated

One month (plus a little bit) into the New 52, here's my updated pull list:

Day-And-Date
  • Justice League--definitely staying on this list
  • Action Comics--definitely staying on this list
  • Batgirl--definitely staying on this list
  • Justice League International--still on this list for the time being, but I might drop it to the Month Late list if it doesn't wow me soon
  • Stormwatch--definitely staying on this list
  • Batman and Robin--definitely staying on this list
  • Batwoman--definitely staying on this list
  • Green Lantern--as mentioned here, I decided to wait on Green Lantern titles until the "War of the Green Lanterns" goes on sale... still hasn't happened...
  • Batman--definitely staying on this list
  • Green Lantern Corps--see Green Lantern above
  • Nightwing--definitely staying on this list
  • Red Hood and the Outlaws--ugh. The first issue was not quite offensive enough for me to drop altogether, but I'm going to wait at least long enough to read the reviews of issue 2 before buying it. I'd like to hear whether people are convinced by Lobdell's defense of Starfire after reading the issue. 
  • Wonder Woman--staying on this list for now; not necessarily my favorite book, but pretty good nonetheless
  • Aquaman--definitely staying on this list
  • Flash--definitely staying on this list
  • Green Lantern: New Guardians--see Green Lantern above
  • Superman--definitely staying on this list
  • Teen Titans--definitely staying on this list


A Month Late and a Dollar Short
  • Animal Man--not quite awesome enough to move up to the Day-And-Date list, but pretty darn close
  • Batwing--sure, I'll keep reading this
  • Detective Comics--sure, I'll keep reading this
  • Green Arrow--I'll read at least until Ann Nocenti takes over, to see how she does
  • Static Shock--ditto, except Marc Bernardin instead of Ann Nocenti
  • Swamp Thing--I dunno, I'll give it a couple more issues
  • Grifter--I was only somewhat interested in this one and it didn't get great reviews, so I probably won't buy it afterall
  • Legion Lost
  • Mister Terrific
  • Superboy
  • Birds of Prey
  • Blue Beetle
  • Captain Atom
  • Catwoman--this is a case where I'm glad I read the reviews before buying. Saved myself two dollars.
  • Legion of Super-heroes
  • Supergirl
  • The Fury of Firestorm
  • Justice League Dark
  • The Savage Hawkman
  • Frankenstein, Agent of S.H.A.D.E.--the Flashpoint mini convinced me to add this to my list. I'll let you know tomorrow what I think of the first issue
  • Demon Knights--Stormwatch convinced me to give this one a shot. I'll also report on it tomorrow.

Monday, August 29, 2011

My Digital Pull List: The New 35... maybe 36

With tomorrow's midnight release of Justice League 1, the New 52 begins. (Incidentally, I'm curious to see whether there will be a midnight release on Comixology since DC has given retailers the option, and if so what time zone's midnight it will be. If Justice League 1 is in fact released digitally at, say, midnight Eastern time, I'll be reviewing it within an hour thereof.) At any rate, since the subtitle of this blog is "My Digital Pull List," I thought it would be appropriate to actually list the titles I plan on getting. Since I'll be buying only the comics I'm most anxious for on the day they're released and waiting a month to buy the rest when the price drops a dollar, I'm dividing the titles into two lists (each subject to change without warning). Also, a word or two on why I'm planning to buy each one. Without further ado:

Day-And-Date

  • Justice League--because, duh, Geoff Johns + Jim Lee + World's Greatest Heroes (tm)
  • Action Comics--see above, but insert Grant Morrison + Rags Morales in Geoff and Jim's spots, and lose the plural on Heroes
  • Batgirl--I'm a little skeptical about Babs losing the wheelchair and the Oracle identity, but if anyone can pull it off, it's Gail Simone
  • Justice League International--I enjoyed Generation Lost and although this is not by the same writer, it looks like it's going for a similar feel, capturing the essence of the Giffen/DeMatteis League without trying to recreate it
  • Stormwatch--I loved the Authority trades I read a while back, I love the idea of mixing J'onn in with Wildstorm characters, and there just aren't enough comics starring a Superman analogue and a Batman analogue who are in love
  • Batman and Robin--Tomasi and Gleason do good stuff, plus this looks like the place I'll be getting my Damian fix
  • Batwoman--Pretty pictures with the added bonus of supporting a book that stars a gay female lead
  • Green Lantern--As hesitant as I usually am to jump on bandwagons, I've been on the Geoff Johns bandwagon for some time now
  • Batman--Batman is my first love, and I've been hearing good things about this Scott Snyder chap, so I'm excited to read his stuff
  • Green Lantern Corps--Seems like a package deal with Green Lantern
  • Nightwing--My other first love
  • Red Hood and the Outlaws--I was a little skeptical when I first heard about this, but the more I hear the more intrigued I am by the idea of putting these former Titans together on the road to redemption; also, I recently read Winick's Red Hood miniseries and that made me actually like the character for the first time
  • Wonder Woman--Honestly, I'm not as in love with Azzarrello as I think I'm supposed to be, but I'm curious to see what he does with Diana; also, I loves me some Cliff Chiang
  • Aquaman--Geoff Johns has done right by every other character he's taken under his wing, so I have faith he'll do a good Aquaman
  • Flash--I guess character loyalty more than anything, though I admit to being a Wally fan more than a Barry fan; I'm curious to see if Francis Manapul writes as well as he draws
  • Green Lantern: New Guardians--see Green Lantern Corps above; also, Kyle is my Green Lantern
  • Superman--Package deal with Action, plus George Perez has a history of doing well with freshly rebooted characters
  • Teen Titans--This is one of two titles, along with Justice League, that I will always buy no matter who's on the team and no matter who the creators are, because that's the kind of comic book reader I am; even though I'm a little turned off by the idea of erasing the characters' history and drastically changing them, my fears are somewhat put to rest by recent interviews with Scott Lobdell where he insists the characters are the same at their core--hopefully this is at least true in the case of Tim Drake, my third first love


A Month Late and a Dollar Short

  • Animal Man--I've always liked the character and I've heard good things about Jeff Lemire, so I'm willing to give this book a chance
  • Batwing--Judd Winick is hit-and-miss for me, so I'll give him a chance to hit me with this one
  • Detective Comics--I don't have a lot of faith in Tony Daniel as a writer (though his art has improved much over the past years), but I have been enjoying his run on Batman well enough
  • Green Arrow--I'm enjoying JT Krul's current run on GA enough to read this, just not enough to make a must-read-right-now
  • Static Shock--I like the character, plus I feel the need to support books featuring minority characters (so long as I have a genuine interest in the book; I'm not buying, for example, Voodoo)
  • Swamp Thing--I'm giving this book a try purely based on the fact that everyone is talking about how great Scott Snyder is lately; I've never been hooked by the character before, despite giving him several chances, so we'll see how long this book keeps my interest
  • Grifter--Still haven't decided for sure on this one; initially I was interested because it looked like he was going to be hunting white Martians and I liked the DC/Wildstorm mashup concept, but now it's looking like they're some other species so I don't know whether I'm still interested
  • Legion Lost--I dig the Legion and I dig Nicieza (his run on Red Robin has been fantastic); I'll be pissed, though, if Gates really dies in the first issue
  • Mister Terrific--Mainly I'm just curious to see how he works as a solo character, especially if the JSA is no longer part of this universe's history
  • Superboy--Mainly interested because it looks like this will be closely tied to Teen Titans
  • Birds of Prey--Right now my only reason for buying this book is Black Canary, despite her god-awful costume redesign; the creative team is going to have to convince me to keep reading
  • Blue Beetle--His last book was pure awesome, so Tony Bedard has some big shoes to fill; I'm not crazy about the fact that it appears they're starting over from scratch, essentially retelling a story that was told only a few years ago
  • Captain Atom--It looks like they're trying to make the character more Dr. Manhattany, which may or may not work; buying this mainly because I've generally enjoyed JT Krul's stuff so far
  • Catwoman--See Batwing above
  • Legion of Super-heroes--Again, I love the Legion; since they're in the future and don't interact with other books much I figure I can afford to wait a month for this one; as a side note, I think it's dumb to hyphenate "super-heroes," but that's how it's solicited
  • Supergirl--As with Blue Beetle, I'm not crazy about the idea of starting over from scratch yet again with this character, but I'm not 100% certain that's what they're doing; honestly, I just want Peter David to come back and bring Linda Danvers with him
  • The Fury of Firestorm--I've always found the character visually appealing, and I kind of like the Jason/Ronnie combo, and Gail Simone has never written a single word I didn't enjoy (her thes are great)
  • Justice League Dark--I can't say I'm a big fan of any of these characters nor of magical characters in general, but Peter Milligan is one of those writers I'm supposed to like, so I'm giving this a chance to wow me
  • The Savage Hawkman--Like I said, I don't have much faith in Tony Daniel as a writer, but I've always had a soft spot for buff men who don't wear shirts


A few notes on what I'm not getting:

  • As much as I think it's good for DC to be trying non-superhero genres, I'm trusting that those books will find their audience without me. Just not into war comics or westerns or swords and sorcery. 
  • Even though I think I'm supposed to like Peter Milligan, I don't want to read a monthly comic about an entire corps of characters whose power is to barf up blood.
  • I may check out DC Universe Presents in the future, but I have never been able to care about Deadman.
  • I'm kind of sort of interested in Frankenstein: Agent of S.H.A.D.E., but money doesn't grow on trees, you know. Ditto for Hawk & Dove. 
  • I like Harley Quinn, but I'm waiting for a book that has a character that actually looks like her before I buy it. And seriously, what's with King Shark's eyes?
  • Sorry, Dan Didio, you're welcome to hire yourself as a writer, but that doesn't mean I want to read what you write.